Warning! Are you making this email list faux pas?

Warning! Are you making this email list faux pas?

Email list faux pas

Let’s say you’re about to make your very first email list (although even if you already have a plump one, keep reading because you could also unwittingly commit an email list faux pas!).

You may have…

  • Tons of contacts in your Gmail account
  • Piles of paper with people’s names and emails who signed when you held a conference in 2012
  • A shoe box that previously housed work pumps, now stuffed with business cards from the 947 networking events you’ve attended in the last 5 years

So you’re thinkin’ …

“Eureka! I’ll put all these contacts into my list on MailChimp and start my email marketing with dozens or hundreds of subscribers before I even send out my first newzletter — BAM!”

STOP. RIGHT. THERE. Sister.

I beg ya. Don’t commit that email list faux pas.

Since I see this question a lot from all types of small business owners, let’s tackle it like it’s a hot bicyclist.

Apologies for tornado-ing on your parade, but here’s why adding all your contacts to your list is problematic (and will land you into bigger trouble than when you were caught shoplifting mint nail polish at age 12) and what to do instead.

Avoid a deadly email list faux pas by choosing one of the following alternatives:

  1. Set up an opt-in on your website and let your list fill itself (without adding your existing contacts to it yourself). Just set up an opt-in and drive traffic to your website by promoting your smarts in networking groups, social media, telling your mom to call everyone in her leather bound phone book, etc.
  2. Email the people you think would be interested — those people whose business cards you forgot you had, the ones who scribbled their name on your “Sign up to stay updated!” sheet at your last workshop, the ones you sat with at a nonprofit fundraiser last spring that had ’90s hairdos. Tell them what you do and how your services or products can help them (or describe your ideal client to them). And, of course, include the link to your opt-in (on your website or perhaps a pre-website “Coming Soon” page). That way, you’re letting them sign up themselves.

So why the hassle?

WHY ARE YOU KILLING MY DREAM OF HAVING 300 SUBSCRIBERS BEFORE I EVEN START MARKETING MYSELF, NAT? You know it pumps me up so hard I wanna make gnocchi from scratch (now that’s a freakin’ hassle)!

Sorry, chipmunk.

I’ll explain: Letting people sign up to your list themselves rather than you doing it for them (most likely without their permission) will help protect you from having miffed subscribers mark your emails as spam, which eventually puts you on MailChimp’s (or Aweber’s or Ontraport’s etc.) blacklist because you’d be violating national or international anti-spam laws.

And speaking of anti-spam laws, violating them can mean many thousands of dollars in penalties (try $16,000!).

So let’s just not go there. Let’s go hiking in the woods and eat banana-coconut pancakes instead. Can I get a, “hellz yeah!”? (Hellz yeah!)

Hey, I’ve been working on a DIY MailChimp course…

…that includes not just important tips like the ones in this post, but also hours of easy peasy step-by-step tutorials so you can set up your email marketing system and be done like Dan in one afternoon. Boom.

Wanna be notified of the early bird discount?

Sign up here to get all the deets!

What to save on and what to splurge on with your website

What to save on and what to splurge on with your website

I may be a web designer/developer who knows her stuff (both tech and pastry-related), but I still make my fair share of mistakes — even on what to save on and what to splurge on. Example: At the beginning, I was using a cheap hosting provider. Eventually, I got a bigger, more expensive plan… but thatRead more

How to boost your marketing with a responsive website

How to boost your marketing with a responsive website

Over 60% of your website visitors are checking out your site on their phones or tablets. That means that if you don’t have a responsive website — one that “responds” to different sized screens and looks fabulous on mobile devices in addition to computer screens — you’re probably turning off most of the people whoRead more

The difference between graphic design, web design and web development

The difference between graphic design, web design and web development

Jargon can suck. I want us to be on the same page. And I bet you may have some questions about this whole “web design” thing: what the hell is web development? And aren’t web design and graphic design the same thing? I don’t even… huh? Hey, I get it! There was a time whenRead more

What you need before I can build you a website that sells

What you need before I can build you a website that sells

After dozens of nights going to bed as the sun crawls out of the horizon, continuing to refine my skills, and adding a brilliant graphic designer to my team (who is rebranding my website, BTW!), I’m booked out for another month and have just 4 spots available to work with me before 2015. In the process, I’veRead more

8 ways to get your business off the ground

8 ways to get your business off the ground

Being an entrepreneur is H-A-R-D (and can also be F-U-N and A-W-E-S-O-M-E). But, dude, it’s work. And if you haven’t/don’t have a sharp-as-a-samurai-sword business or marketing coach, or a mastermind full of insightful and motivating colleagues to push you forward with support and speed, it’s even more challenging. But it doesn’t have to be soRead more

10 best plugins for coaches (make your website run itself!)

10 best plugins for coaches (make your website run itself!)

You know where I’m going with this, don’t you? I’m gonna talk about WordPress plugins, those little digital elves that take care of essential, boring, and awesome tasks to keep your site running smoothly and so you can spend more time away from the computer. (Hi, fresh air and sunshine! Remember me?!) Because I’m allRead more

5 ways to shave time and money with your website (audio!)

5 ways to shave time and money with your website (audio!)

Managing a website can be time-consuming. Like, aaaargh time-consuming. And boring! But there are smart shortcuts to shave time and money off your website-tending duties. Because instead of emailing back and forth with dozens of people who wanna get on the phone with you to see if you’re a kickass fit or — even moreRead more

10 things I learned in my first year of business (audio!)

10 things I learned in my first year of business (audio!)

I’m no business coach, but I’ve learned a bajillion things since I became Website Superhero full-time a year ago (and the months before that when I was a web designer/developer part-time). And I’d like to share some of them with ya. I’ve made 10,894,112 mistakes, failed, cried, freaked out… and also experienced a ton of laughter,Read more

5 ways to make your website turn visitors into customers

5 ways to make your website turn visitors into customers

As Website Superhero, I both design/develop websites and analyze all the sites I see when I read woo woo blog posts, stumble upon a drool-worthy recipe for raw vegan vanilla chocolate mousse cake, or geek out on best practices. What works? What doesn’t? What’s so genius I wanna hug it? What’s so god-awful I facepalm myself? What would boost conversionsRead more